
A display showing the orbits of thousands of Starlink satellites operated by the US space company SpaceX, owned by billionaire Elon Musk, March 2024.
Keystone-SDA
The growing use of military satellites, cyber capabilities and anti-satellite weapons is raising fears that competition in space could one day turn into conflict.
An unusual manoeuvre recently took place over our heads. The Russian military satellite Kosmos 2612 approached the Finnish satellite Iceye-X36, which provides Ukraine with satellite images. This “orbit stalker” deliberately moved even closer to the Finnish radar satellite.
At times, only a few hundred metres separated the two. While this may sound like a safe distance, the spacecraft were so close that radar data occasionally registered them as a single object rather than two separate satellites.
Power games in orbit
“This is worrying,” says Clémence Poirier, a cyber defence researcher at the Center for Security Studies (CSS) at the federal technology institute ETH Zurich. Since the satellite supplies data to Ukraine, the incident is regarded as a hostile manoeuvre. Exactly what Russia hoped to achieve remains unclear.
Moscow may have been trying to gather intelligence on the satellite’s technology, eavesdrop on it, jam signals or disrupt the Finnish satellite’s links with Earth. It is also possible that the aim was to temporarily interfere with the operations of Iceye-X36External link.

In the war in Ukraine, attack drones linked to the Starlink communications system are playing a key role.
Keystone-SDA
“States are preparing for a war in space,” Poirier warns. A few weeks ago, the US officially acknowledged that it had weapons in orbit. Britain soon followed, admitting that it too had deployed weapons in space, she says. Various countries are developing counterspace capabilities to prepare for hostile attacks. France, for example, plans to deploy small patrol satellites around larger military satellites.
>>Listen to our podcast with Clémence Poirier, senior cyber defence researcher at the ETH Zurich’s Center for Security Studies:
More

More
Science podcast: why threats in space should concern everyone on Earth
And Russia, China, the US and India all possess anti-satellite missiles that can be launched from Earth, says Poirier. All four countries have demonstrated these capabilities by destroying their own satellites in orbit, generating vast quantities of space debris.
A large share of the debris circling Earth today can be traced to China’s anti-satellite test of 2007 and the 2009 collision between a deactivated Russian satellite and a US communications satellite.
Military branch of Starlink
Satellites have become indispensable for modern warfare, serving as the digital backbone of the battlefield. They not only provide reconnaissance imagery but also enable communications and navigation, both critical for controlling drones. Their strategic importance was demonstrated when the Ukrainian armed forces faced restrictions on Elon Musk’s Starshield, Space X’s military-grade Starlink network, from mid-October until recently.
Ukraine relies on both the civilian Starlink service and its military counterpart Starshield. When the latter temporarily reduced connection speeds, fast interception and attack drones lost connectivity. The restrictions have since been lifted and the service restoredExternal link.
How dependent modern societies are on space-based infrastructure became clear at the start of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, when the satellite network of US company Viasat was targeted. Across Europe, 30,000 modems failed, and wind turbines in Germany could no longer be controlled remotely. The affected modems had to be completely replaced. The attack affected the ability of the Ukrainian Armed Forces to coordinate their response to the invasion.
Rise in cyberthreats
“For the space community, this was a Pearl Harbor moment,” says Poirier. The incident served as a wake-up call and fundamentally changed attitudes towards cybersecurity in space. Electronic and cyber operations against space systems have increased in recent years.
In 2025, ETH Zurich identified 407 cyber incidents affecting the space sectorExternal link, many linked to armed conflicts and crisis situations. That is roughly one attack per day. For Europe in particular, the question is how to better protect its own systems.

The European Ariane 6 rocket launches from Europe’s spaceport in French Guyana carrying satellites.
Esa
Although Europe often trails the US, China and Russia, it still possesses considerable expertise in space. “With Ariane 6, it has independent access to space, operates military communications satellites and has developed its Earth observation and navigation systems via Copernicus and Galileo,” says Poirier.
Europe’s answer to Starlink
With IRIS² (Infrastructure for Resilience, Interconnectivity and Security by Satellite),External link Europe is building its own version of Starlink, although the constellation is not expected to enter service before 2030. The project has been slowed by Europe’s complex decision-making structures and the large number of stakeholders involved. However, Poirier is convinced that it will succeed. “It will work. It just takes longer and costs more than expected,” she says.
The planned network will provide secure communications for governments, armed forces and critical infrastructure operators while reducing Europe’s dependence on non-European providers. IRIS² will consist of 330 satellites in low Earth orbit (LEO) and 18 in medium Earth orbit (MEO). An additional 66 satellites are earmarked specifically for defence, security and emergency services.
Until IRIS² becomes operational, probably in 2030 at the earliest, Europe can continue to rely on existing systems, such as Eutelsat’s OneWeb. Although far smaller than SpaceX’s gigantic satellite system, OneWeb currently operates more than 600 active satellites in low Earth orbitExternal link at an altitude of 1,200 kilometres.
Starlink therefore does not have a monopoly, says Poirier. Nevertheless, Musk’s company occupies a dominant position in satellite communications and launch services. “Russia has also used Starlink in Ukraine at times by capturing user terminals on the battlefield or acquiring them on the second-hand market,” she adds. SpaceX responded by introducing a whitelist security control system that restricted access to authorised users and devices.
IRIS² – not an option for Switzerland
But what does this mean for Switzerland? “It will not have access to the capabilities of IRIS² because it is not an EU member state,” says Poirier. As with the Galileo system, Swiss companies could supply specialised components such as atomic clocks. But so far, no firm agreements have been reached.
Could Switzerland launch its own project? Building its own mega-constellation in low Earth orbit would make little financial sense, Poirier explains. “Developing one or several geostationary communications satellites would be a more realistic option.”
Yet even for countries and companies that can afford ambitious satellite programmes, another challenge is becoming increasingly clear. How to get all these satellites into space? Available launch capacity is struggling to keep pace with growing demand for mega-constellations. Amazon’s Kuiper network has already secured launches on Europe’s Ariane 6 rocket. China’s Qianfan constellation, which aims to deploy 15,000 satellites and has already launched more than 250, is also grappling with limited launch capacity.
The problem could become even more acute in the coming years. SpaceX plans to replace Falcon 9 with its next-generation Starship system in the long term. For operators heavily dependent on Falcon launches, this creates uncertainty. “Transport is the big bottleneck,” says Poirier.
Demand for access to space is growing rapidly. Expanding rocket production, however, requires massive investment, lengthy regulatory approvals and new production facilities. Supply chain problems affecting critical rocket components have added further pressure to the sector over the past five years.
Soon 100,000 satellites in orbit?
The use of space will expand in the future. More than 11,000 of the roughly 14,000 active satellites currently in orbit belong to Elon Musk’s Starlink network. But SpaceX wants to expand even further and is far from alone. China, Europe, RussiaExternal link and private competitors are also pushing ahead with the development of their own mega-constellations. The European Space Agency (ESA) estimates that up to 100,000 satellites could be orbiting EarthExternal link by 2030.

Two Starlink satellites can be seen as streaks of light in the night sky (photograph taken with an exposure time of 15 seconds).
Keystone-SDA
The space race has entered a new phase. Yet the growing number of satellites also increases the risks. Every new satellite raises the risk of collisions and additional debris. Millions of debris fragments already circle Earth. According to Poirier, an object just one centimetre across can destroy a satellite weighing several tonnes.
At the same time, the line between civilian and military applications is becoming increasingly blurred. Many technologies today are dual use. A robotic arm that collects space debris could, for example, be used tomorrow to push another satellite out of its orbit. And in space, Poirier notes, there are no traffic rules like those governing roads or airspace.
Translated from German, sub-edited by Simon Bradley/ts

